Compare real options

Use this when you're choosing between concrete options and want to see the tradeoffs together. Set the criteria before asking for a recommendation.

Prompt template

Compare [options] for [use case] using these criteria: [criteria]. Build a table with benefits, tradeoffs, dependencies, and unanswered questions. Mark assumptions. Do not invent prices or features. Explain what information would change the comparison.

Boundary: Produce only the comparison and a conditional recommendation. Keep the supplied options, facts, prices, and criteria intact. Leave source material unchanged; don't buy, book, or select an option on my behalf.

Fill in this prompt in the builder

What to supply

  • The options and the decision you need to make.
  • Your criteria, supplied costs or specifications, and any fixed limits.

Worked example

Illustrative example: the input and result below are invented.

Input

Maya, 34, needs storage for 80 small stock items. Option A has capacity for 100 items, costs $120, and requires wall mounting. Option B holds 90 items, costs $150, and stands on the floor. Maya can spend up to $160 but can't drill into the wall.

Filled-in prompt

Show the complete prompt
Compare two storage options (A: 100-item capacity, $120, wall-mounted; B: 90-item capacity, $150, floor-standing) for storing 80 small stock items in a rented shop where wall drilling isn't allowed using these criteria: capacity at least 80; cost at most $160; no wall drilling; stability and footprint still unknown. Build a table with benefits, tradeoffs, dependencies, and unanswered questions. Mark assumptions. Do not invent prices or features. Explain what information would change the comparison.

Boundary: Produce only the comparison and a conditional recommendation. Keep the supplied options, facts, prices, and criteria intact. Leave source material unchanged; don't buy, book, or select an option on my behalf.

Result

A: Capacity and budget fit; wall mounting conflicts with the no-drilling requirement.
B: Capacity and budget fit; floor-standing design avoids the stated mounting conflict.
Provisional choice: B fits the supplied fixed requirements. Stability, dimensions, and delivery costs still need checking.
What could change the comparison: Approved mounting permission for A, an unsuitable footprint for B, or additional costs that exceed the budget.

What I’d check or correct

I'd check that the assistant didn't award A extra points for capacity while overlooking the fixed mounting restriction. B's suitability is provisional until its footprint and stability are known.

What to check

  • Every option uses the same criteria, with fixed requirements respected.
  • The result only compares the supplied options and leaves specifications, prices, and your priorities unchanged.
  • The recommendation identifies the missing fact that could reverse it.

Related pages

Share this page