Use this when an idea feels settled before you've examined it. Ask for the strongest case on each side and a practical test that could change your mind.
Prompt template
Examine this claim: [claim]. Give the strongest supporting argument, the strongest counterargument, and the assumptions both depend on. Distinguish evidence from speculation. Suggest a practical observation or test that would help me update my view. Boundary: Produce an analysis of the supplied claim and proposed tests only. Leave the original claim, facts, and evidence intact. Don't claim test results or decide what I believe.
Fill in this prompt in the builder
What to supply
- One clear claim, including its scope.
- What you already know and what evidence would matter, included with the claim.
Worked example
Illustrative example: the input and result below are invented.
Input
Daniel, 39, is planning an adult-learning class. His working claim is that a shorter explanation always helps beginners learn faster. He wants to examine that claim before cutting the practice instructions.
Filled-in prompt
Show the complete prompt
Examine this claim: A shorter explanation always helps beginners learn faster. Context: an adult-learning class with practice instructions; no learning results have been supplied. Give the strongest supporting argument, the strongest counterargument, and the assumptions both depend on. Distinguish evidence from speculation. Suggest a practical observation or test that would help me update my view. Boundary: Produce an analysis of the supplied claim and proposed tests only. Leave the original claim, facts, and evidence intact. Don't claim test results or decide what I believe.
Result
Supporting case: Removing repetition can make the first step easier to find. Counterargument: Cutting a worked example or prerequisite can leave a beginner unable to start. Assumptions: Both arguments depend on what was removed, the learner's starting knowledge, and how learning is judged. Proposed test that could change the view: Compare whether learners can complete the same first step and explain why it works after two versions of the explanation. Keep the task and starting conditions comparable. Open question: Does 'faster' mean reading less or doing the skill sooner?
What I’d check or correct
I'd check that the answer challenges the word 'always' without pretending either argument is a measured result. I'd also keep the comparison focused on learning, which is the claim Daniel actually made.
What to check
- Both sides address the strongest version of the same claim.
- The result analyzes the claim and leaves your original statement and evidence intact.
- The proposed test could distinguish the arguments without assuming its outcome.